21stcenturyjudaism

Are Jews a People?

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp

In Jewish tradition, Abraham is referred to as ‘Avraham Avinu,’ the father of the Jewish people.

Lately, however, it has become sort of trendy to question whether Jews are indeed a people.

Using a reductionist definition equating “people” with “ethnos,” “nation,” and “race,” some academics, such as emeritus Tel Aviv University history professor Shlomo Sand have questioned whether the Jews are, in fact, descendants of Abraham.

 The question, so framed, is significant because of its conclusion. As professor Sand wrote in his 2008 book The Invention of the Jewish People:

“I have been accused of denying the existence of the Jewish people, and I have to acknowledge that this assertion … is not totally unfounded.”

Before Moses, King David, and Theodore Herzl, the TaNaKh says about Abraham:

I have singled him out so that he may instruct his children and his posterity to keep the way of the Lord by doing what is just and right …

Whereas social scientists look for linguistic, geographical, and biological markers, among others, to diagnose a people’s existence, Jews, from Abraham on, have determined that what makes us a people is our sense of mission. From there on it is a sense of common shared history and a sense of unique collective solidarity that seals the bonds of Jewish peoplehood.

Because the cornerstone is having a mission, it is not so much the path that defines Israel’s peoplehood; rather, it is its future.

Martin Buber, one of the founders of the Hebrew University, wrote that the spirit of Israel is the … fulfillment of the simple truth that the human being has been created for a purpose. There is a purpose to the creation, and there is a purpose to the human race, one we have not made ourselves or agreed to among ourselves; we have not decided that henceforward this, that, or the other shall serve the purpose of our existence. No, the purpose itself revealed its face to us, and we have gazed upon it.”

And for good measure he added on another occasion that the important thing “is not whether we feel or do not feel that we are chosen…” but “that our role in history actually has been unique.”

Israel’s peoplehood begins with Abraham, and his charge and teaching are what define it.

The book of Devarim (Deuteronomy) opens by describing how Moses gathered the Israelites on the plains of Moab after conquering the Jordan’s east bank.

Standing near Mount Nebo, Moses recounted the events of the past to the new cohort of Israelites approaching the Promised Land.

This generation was quite different from the one that had left Egypt. They had no firsthand experience with the Exodus or the desert tribulations.

Moses’s account of the previous events centers on the missed opportunities and the repercussions of fear and disobedience.

Not surprisingly, this section of the Torah is read before Tisha B’Av, the annual commemoration of a multitude of calamities in Jewish history, most notably the destruction of Solomon’s Temple by the Neo-Babylonian Empire and the Second Temple by the Roman Empire in Jerusalem.

The causes of the destruction of the Temples—traditionally linked to baseless hatred and the people’s internal corruption—parallel the spiritual mistakes that Moses warned about in Devarim (literally, “remarks”).

The message of Moses here is clear. Building a stable and hopeful future requires facing communal failings and honestly recounting Israel’s past. The whole book of Devarim is dedicated to setting the groundwork for this human project.

Devarim is profoundly worried that social inequality and idolatry are undermining societal unity, so it revises the previous rules in Shemot (Exodus) to provide more rights to the poor and women.

Probably no other book of the Torah would be more relevant, addressing the Jewish people’s present current situation and speaking to a generation that had not witnessed the Holocaust, the creation of the State of Israel, and the consistent rejection of those who cannot see history other than as a zero-sum dynamic and cannot turn failures into the kind of meaning on which the future is built.

 

In Jewish tradition, Abraham is referred to as ‘Avraham Avinu,’ the father of the Jewish people.

Lately, however, it has become sort of trendy to question whether Jews are indeed a people.

Using a reductionist definition equating “people” with “ethnos,” “nation,” and “race,” some academics, such as emeritus Tel Aviv University history professor Shlomo Sand have questioned whether the Jews are, in fact, descendants of Abraham.

 The question, so framed, is significant because of its conclusion. As professor Sand wrote in his 2008 book The Invention of the Jewish People:

“I have been accused of denying the existence of the Jewish people, and I have to acknowledge that this assertion … is not totally unfounded.”

Before Moses, King David, and Theodore Herzl, the TaNaKh says about Abraham:

I have singled him out so that he may instruct his children and his posterity to keep the way of the Lord by doing what is just and right …

Whereas social scientists look for linguistic, geographical, and biological markers, among others, to diagnose a people’s existence, Jews, from Abraham on, have determined that what makes us a people is our sense of mission. From there on it is a sense of common shared history and a sense of unique collective solidarity that seals the bonds of Jewish peoplehood.

Because the cornerstone is having a mission, it is not so much the path that defines Israel’s peoplehood; rather, it is its future.

Martin Buber, one of the founders of the Hebrew University, wrote that the spirit of Israel is the … fulfillment of the simple truth that the human being has been created for a purpose. There is a purpose to the creation, and there is a purpose to the human race, one we have not made ourselves or agreed to among ourselves; we have not decided that henceforward this, that, or the other shall serve the purpose of our existence. No, the purpose itself revealed its face to us, and we have gazed upon it.”

And for good measure he added on another occasion that the important thing “is not whether we feel or do not feel that we are chosen…” but “that our role in history actually has been unique.”

Israel’s peoplehood begins with Abraham, and his charge and teaching are what define it.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp

Never miss any important news. Subscribe to our newsletter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *